Traditional Pies

Discover Our Authentic Traditional Pies Made Fresh Daily

Since 1980, La Roma Pastry Shop has been crafting traditional pies using authentic Italian family recipes and grade-A ingredients. Every pie is made fresh daily with over 50 years of combined experience, bringing you the taste of Italy close to home. Our made-to-order pies deliver tradition you can taste in every bite. We offer same-day orders, in-store pickup, and delivery options through GrubHub and DoorDash, plus local and nationwide shipping.

Visit us today and taste handcrafted quality in every slice.

When You Want a Traditional Pie

Few desserts are as comforting and timeless as a freshly baked traditional pie. At La Roma Pastry Shop, we create delicious pies using quality ingredients, time-honored recipes, and the care and craftsmanship that have made us a trusted bakery for generations.

• Fresh traditional pies handcrafted with premium ingredients and exceptional care
• Classic pie varieties featuring the flavors customers have loved for years
• Perfect for holidays, family gatherings, celebrations, and special occasions
• Flaky, golden crusts and flavorful fillings in every slice
• A delicious dessert to enjoy with coffee, espresso, tea, or your favorite beverage

Whether you're celebrating a special occasion, bringing dessert to a gathering, or simply satisfying a craving, our traditional pies deliver the perfect blend of homemade flavor and quality. From cherished classics to customer favorites, every pie is baked to impress and made with attention to every detail.

Why Choose La Roma Pastry Shop

For decades, La Roma Pastry Shop has been serving the community with exceptional desserts, authentic Italian specialties, and outstanding customer service.

• Fresh traditional pies made with premium-quality ingredients
• Over 50 years of baking experience and craftsmanship
• Wide selection of classic pies for holidays, gatherings, and everyday enjoyment
• Time-honored recipes combined with meticulous attention to quality and detail
• Comfortable dining area where you can enjoy pie, coffee, pastries, and conversation
• Wide selection of fresh pastries, cakes, desserts, and imported Italian products
• Friendly, knowledgeable staff dedicated to outstanding customer service
• Multilingual staff speaking English, Italian, and Spanish
• Open seven days a week for your convenience

With a commitment to quality and tradition, La Roma Pastry Shop offers more than just delicious traditional pies. We provide a welcoming place where friends, families, and neighbors can gather to enjoy handcrafted desserts, premium coffee, and genuine hospitality. Whether you're enjoying a slice in our dining area or taking a pie home to share with loved ones, you'll taste the difference that comes from decades of baking excellence and dedication to customer satisfaction.

Contact Us

Ready to order your perfect traditional pie? La Roma Pastry Shop is here to serve you seven days a week in Oakdale, NY. Our locally, family-owned bakery offers catering for any number of people, holiday catering, and custom orders to meet your needs. We speak English, Italian, and Spanish to better serve our community.

Stop in today and enjoy your pie in our comfortable shop, or reach out to place your order or join our rewards program.